I'm trying to do this quest, but something odd keeps happening: When I find one of the cats, I click the food on it to get it in my inventory, but... it only work for less than 1 second. It says "The party has gained an item", with the cat mewing and all, and then the cat just re-appeared on the ground, mewing, as if I dropped it.
Consequently, I don't have the cat with me, and I wasted one food. I keep trying, but the same thing keeps happening.
I've lot of space for the cats, but to no avail. Am I the only one with this problem?